Let’s be real: arguing about the best pizza in New York City is basically a local pastime. Some people play chess in the park, some train for the marathon, and the rest of us? We debate pizza.
Everyone’s got an opinion. Your cousin swears by some hole-in-the-wall spot in Brooklyn. Your coworker talks about a $38 truffle slice like it’s a life-changing experience.
But here at Nice Guy Tours, we keep it simple: The best pizza in NYC? Bleecker Street Pizza.
What Makes Bleecker Street Pizza So Special?
First of all, it’s got history. We’re talking about a place that’s been serving up slices since 2004—basically forever in New York pizza years. It’s won Best Pizza in NYC so many times that at this point, they should probably just retire the trophy.
But let’s get to the important part: the pizza.
The signature slice here is the Nonna Maria—a thin, crisp crust topped with fresh mozzarella, a rich, garlicky tomato sauce, basil, and a sprinkle of parmesan. It’s simple. It’s perfect. It’s like a warm hug from an Italian grandmother, except you don’t have to pretend to like her weird homemade cookies afterward.
The Atmosphere
Bleecker Street Pizza isn’t fancy. It doesn’t need to be. You walk in, you order at the counter, you grab your slice, and you let the magic happen. There’s no velvet rope, no Michelin star pretension—just really, really good pizza.
And let’s talk location. You’ll find this legendary pizza joint right in the heart of Greenwich Village, a neighborhood so full of character that even the pigeons have strong opinions about art. It’s the perfect spot to grab a slice and stroll, maybe do some people-watching, and—if you’re lucky—overhear some ridiculous first-date conversations.
Why You Need to Try It on the Greenwich Village Tour
If you join our Greenwich Village Food Tour, Bleecker Street Pizza is one of the stars of the show. We’ll take you there, get you the good stuff, and you won’t even have to stress about what to order. (Although let’s be honest, the answer is always the Nonna Maria.)
You could hunt for “the best pizza in NYC” on your own, but why risk it? You might end up with a soggy slice, a burnt crust, or—worst of all—a tourist trap that serves their pizza with a knife and fork. (Shudder.)
Final Thoughts
Look, we’re not here to start a pizza war (unless it’s a deliciously cheesy one). But if you’re in New York and you don’t stop at Bleecker Street Pizza? You’re doing it wrong. Join us on the Greenwich Village Food Tour, take a bite, and see for yourself. We promise it’ll be the best decision you make all day. (Unless you also decide to adopt a puppy. That would be pretty great too.)
Hungry yet? Book your tour now!
